|
What is the singular most important fact about Polygraph
Examination everybody should remember?
Everybody should remember that if they lie in the Polygraph examination,
the Polygraph instrument WILL detect deception.
BACK
TO TOP
Can anyone force me to take Polygraph examination?
In order for a Polygraph examination to be administrated properly you
must sit still and not move any part of your body. Since the Polygraphist
must have this co-operation from you, you must volunteer for the test.
If for any reason you don't want to take the examination, you should certainly
refuse the test.
BACK
TO TOP
What is crucial to remember when searching for a Polygraph
Examiner?
Make sure that the Examiner has completed Polygraph Examiner training
in one of American Polygraph Association accredited institutions. The
Amercian Polygraph Association requires at least eight weeks training.
This will ensure that a validated Polygraph examination is conducted.
BACK
TO TOP
What is Polygraph?
The term "poly-graph" means "many-writings" and it refers to the manner
in which selected physiological activities are simultaneously recorded.
A Polygraph instrument measures at least three physiological reactions;
respiratory system (breathing pattern), cardio-vascular activity (blood
pressure and blood volume) and galvanic skin response (sweat gland activity).
When administrated by a competent examiner the Polygraph test is one of
the most accurate means available to determine truth and deception.
BACK
TO TOP
Is Polygraph examination dangerous for individual's health?
Not at all. Nevertheless pregnant women should not be tested.
BACK
TO TOP
Who uses Polygraph examinations?
According to the American Polygraph Association they are over fifty-seven
countries using Polygraph testing within three major segments of communities;
Law-enforcement and national security agencies (for pre-employment checking
of police candidates and/or screening of existing officers and agents),
Legal community (to determine the truthfulness of accuser's statements),
Private sector (security companies, corporate organisations, insurance
companies etc.), Correctional and Social Services (dealing with sex offenders
and child abusers), and Private citizens (in matters not involving the
legal of criminal justice system).
BACK
TO TOP
Who gets the test results?
Polygraph test results can only be given to a examinee or anyone specifically
designated in writing by the examinee, person(s), firm, corporation, or
governmental agency, who requested the examination.
BACK
TO TOP
How accurate is Polygraph test?
Polygraph examination is the only lie detection technique that has proven
independent scientific reliability and validity studies and peer acceptance
in the world. It is the only lie detection method directly used by many
state and federal government agencies in the world for investigative,
security and intelligence purposes than any other detection of deception
technique available. The Polygraph instrument is the only reliable, validated
tool for detection of deception.
The American Polygraph Association has a compendium of 80 research projects
involving 6,380 examinations. Researcher conducted 12 studies of the validity
of field examinations, following 2,174 field examinations, providing on
average accuracy of 98%. In addition researcher conducted 11 studies involving
the reliability of independent analysis of 1,609 sets of charts from field
examinations confirming by independent evidence, providing an average
accuracy of 92%.
Summaries from some of additional studies of Polygraph examination accuracy;
Bersh, P.J. (1969). Journal of Applied Psychology, 53(5), 399-403.
The lie detection judgments of Polygraph examiners in criminal investigations
conducted by the (US) military services were validated against unanimous
guilt-innocence decisions by a panel of four Judge Advocate General (JAG)
attorneys. Level of agreement was 92%.
Hants, C. R. (1996). The Journal of General Psychology, 123(4)-324.
Data from the files of 41 criminal cases were examined for confirming
information and were rated by two evaluators on the strength of the confirming
information. The decisions of the original examiners were correct 96%
of the time, and the independent evaluators were 93% correct.
Patric, C. J., & Iacano, W. G. (1991). Journal of Applied Psychology,
76(2), 229-238.
Records from independent (Canadian) police files for 402 control question
test (CQTs) conducted during a 5-year period by federal police examiners
in a major Canadian city, the hit rate for identifying guilty subject
was 98%.
Raskin, D. C., Kircher, J. C., Honts, C. R., & Horowitz, S. W. (1988).
Report to the National Institute of Justice. Polygraph charts from examinations
conducted by the U.S. Secret Service were sampled and blindly interpreted
by polygraph examiners and by computer interpretation using algorithms.
Decisions by the original examiners on individual relevant questions ranged
from 91-96% correct on confirmed truthful answers and 85-95% correct on
confirmed deceptive answers.
BACK
TO TOP
I'm telling the truth, but I'm nervous about taking the
examination. How does the instrument tell the difference between nervousness
and lying?
It is quite normal for an innocent person to be nervous, and the Polygraph
examiner (Psychophysiologist) is aware of this. A truthful person maybe
nervous because he/she is afraid of the unknown. More importantly, nervousness
on the Polygraph readings does not appear like deception to the Polygraph
examiner, therefore does not prevent an examiner from distinguishing between
truth and untruth.
BACK
TO TOP
I have high blood pressure. Would that look as though
I'm lying?
While blood pressure is the principal Polygraph recording, it does not
cause the characteristic pattern that results when a person is untruthful.
An untruthful answer appears on Polygraph chart as a characteristic pattern
different from that created by either high or low blood pressure. A truthful
answer is readily apparent, even though a person has a blood pressure
problem. If you are currently under treatment because of a heart condition
or any mental condition, be sure to tell the polygraphist about it.
BACK
TO TOP
Does the test hurt? Will I get an electric shock?
No, the test does NOT hurt and there is NO possibility of you getting
an electric shock. It is most important that during the examination you
be as comfortable as possible. The only discomfort some people experience
is a slight pressure on the arm because of the standard blood pressure
cuff. This is the same kind of upper-arm cuff a doctor uses to determine
your blood pressure, and it is generally no more uncomfortable than when
a doctor takes your pressure. Other than that, there is no discomfort
involved.
BACK
TO TOP
Suppose the instrument says I'm lying when I'm not?
The Polygraph cannot "say" anything. It merely records on a chart your
bodily reactions to the questions you are being asked. It is up to the
Polygraphist to "read" the information your body provides, and he does
so with a high degree of accuracy.
BACK
TO TOP
I heard there would be questions about my sex habits?
Personal and intrusive questions have no place in a properly conducted
Polygraph examination. Questions concerning your sex habits or preferences,
beliefs or opinions regarding racial matters, political beliefs or affiliations,
have no place in a Polygraph examination, unless you are accused of committing
a sex crime and the purpose of the test is for you to prove your innocence.
BACK
TO TOP
Will I know beforehand what the test questions will
be?
Yes. You will be told word for word the exact questions on the test and
you will be asked only those questions you consent. The examination itself
requires "yes" and "no" answers. The Polygraphist will discuss the questions
with you and reword them if necessary until you can easily answer "yes"
or "no" to each one. The test will not begin until you are comfortable
with the questions.
BACK
TO TOP
Will there be a trick questions?
No. The Polygraph examiner is counting on your trust in him/her and your
co-operation. The examiner cannot expect your trust or co-operation if
they do something, which leads you to mistrust him/her. You will know
the questions before the test begins. If you do not wish to have a certain
question(s) asked, just let the Polygraphist know when he reads the questions
to you before the test begins and they will not ask it.
BACK
TO TOP
I feel that a Polygraph Examination is an invasion of
privacy.
A competent Psychophysiologist (Polygraph Examiner) is interested only
in determining if you have been truthful about a particular statement.
If you agree to be examined, it can hardly be termed as invasion of privacy.
Of course, if you do not agree, no examination will be administered. A
Polygraph examination cannot be administrated without the voluntary consent
of the person being examined.
BACK
TO TOP
How long does Polygraph examination take?
Most examinations take approximately two and a half to three hours. This
includes the pre-test interview, question formulation, introduction to
the Polygraph instrument, Polygraph test itself and interpretation of
charts. A re-examination is sometimes necessary.
BACK
TO TOP
What is a re-examination? Will I have to take one?
Polygraphist usually requests a re-examination when he cannot interpret
the first Polygraph recordings. In most instances interpretable recordings
are then obtained during the re-examination. Of course, we never know
in advance whether or not a person will be asked to take a re-examination.
Taking a re-examination is like taking the original examination. If you
want it take it. Once again a re-examination must be voluntary.
BACK
TO TOP
If I take the Polygraph examination whose side is the
Polygraphist going to be on?
Neither side. The aim of Polygraphist is to seek the truth. He must give
careful attention to every person he is examining. Every person, whether
truthful or not, has the right to be examined with dignity and impartiality.
BACK
TO TOP
How can I tell if the Polygraphist knows what he/she
is doing?
This is probably the most important question you can ask before you consent
to take a Polygraph examination. If you have read the proceeding questions
and answers carefully, you know what is expected of a qualified ethical
Polygraphist. If he/she departs from the above described standards, you
should seriously question their professionalism. You would not consent
to surgery by an unqualified doctor, so you should not consent to a Polygraph
examination by an unqualified Polygraphist. There is a method of inquiring
about the professionalism of the Polygraphist before the examination.
Check your Polygraphist's reputation in the professional community. Find
out if he/she is appropriately qualified by accredited institution to
administer a polygraph examination. For example, be certain that he/she
has had specific training/schooling to become a Polygraphist. Every professional
Psychophisiologyst (Polygraph examiner) should be proud to present his/her
professional credentials. There are professional societies with membership
limited to the professional Polygraphist. Any professionally trained Forensic
Psychophisiologyst (Polygraph examiner) should belong to a relevant professional
body. The biggest and the most reputable is the American Polygraph Association,
which through its Ethics and Grievance Committee, fairly and impartially
investigates all allegations of misconduct against members of its Association.
If a person claims or advertises that he/she is a Polygraph examiner,
yet he/she cannot or does not want to produce the evidence of his professional
training with accredited institution, and membership with a relevant association,
do not consent to a Polygraph examination by that person.
BACK
TO TOP
FAQ from The Journal of Polygraph Studies, Volume IV, No.1, July-August,1969
|